Do I Have to Feel Grateful? The Both/And Approach to Hard Seasons

If you've ever been told to "just be grateful" while you were in the middle of something hard, you probably know the feeling that comes next. You're still stressed and now likely annoyed. As if this hard thing means you’re not grateful. And this time of year, with Thanksgiving coming and everyone going around the table saying what they're thankful for, it can feel even more difficult to acknowledge,

Here's the short answer: no, you don't have to feel grateful on command. Gratitude works best when it sits alongside your hard feelings, not on top of them. The version that helps is honest: this is hard, AND this one thing helped.

What is toxic positivity?

Toxic positivity is the idea that you should stay positive no matter what, and that negative feelings are a problem to get rid of as fast as possible. It sounds like:

  • "Look on the bright side."

  • "It could be worse."

  • "Other people have it so much harder."

  • "Just be grateful for what you have."

Usually, the person saying it means well. But the message underneath is "your feelings are too much," and that rarely makes anyone feel better. What is even worse is that sometimes the person saying it is you.

Why “just be grateful" backfires

In my work with adults, I see this a lot. People come in with anxiety, a harsh inner critic, or a season of life that's just plain heavy, and they've already tried to talk themselves out of it. "I have a good job. My family is healthy. Why do I feel like this?"

When gratitude gets used to shut a feeling down, a few things tend to happen:

  • The feeling doesn't go away. Pushing stress down usually just moves it somewhere else, like your sleep, your patience, or your shoulders.

  • You add a layer of shame. Now you're anxious/sad/upset and you feel like a bad person for being that way when you "should" be thankful.

  • Gratitude starts to feel fake. If the practice always comes with pressure, it's easy to resent it, which is the opposite of the point.

The “both/and" approach

The most useful shift I teach is moving from “either/or” to “both/and”.

Either/or sounds like: “I shouldn't be stressed; I have so much to be thankful for." It treats your stress and your gratitude like they're competing, and one has to win. Discrediting one emotion for another is only going to compound on the negative. Maybe not immediately but eventually.

Both/and sounds like: "This is hard: ________. And I'm still grateful for: ________."

For example:

  • "This is hard: work has been so chaotic this month. And I'm still grateful for: my coworker who brought me a little treat to our meeting."

  • "This is hard: the holidays without my grandmother. And I'm still grateful for: the holiday decor she made."

  • "This is hard: The baby was up all night. And I'm still grateful for: that first quiet cup of coffee."

Both parts are true. Neither one cancels out the other. The hard thing does not make the “grateful for” any less, and the gratitude does not mean the hard thing is not valid.

Why both/and works

In CBT, we pay a lot of attention to the words "should" and "but." "I'm grateful, but I'm exhausted" quietly erases the first half. "I should be happy" turns a feeling into a rule you're breaking. Swapping "but" for "and" sounds small, yet it lets your brain hold two true things at once without arguing with itself.

It also lowers the bar. You don't have to feel thankful about the hard thing. You just have to notice one good thing that exists next to it.

Try it this week

Once a day, fill in the both/and sentence. Say it in your head, type it in your notes app, or text it to someone you trust. If the "grateful for" blank stays empty some days, that's okay too. Naming the hard part still counts. Better yet, if the hard part stays blank- let it be.

Next week, I'll share four simple ways to practice gratitude without the pressure, including what to do when finding something you’re grateful for feels too hard.

Gratitude isn't about pretending everything is fine. It's about letting the hard stuff and the good stuff exist at the same time. Life is both, a beautiful mess, never just rainbows but never just rain either.

I work with adults & teens across Ohio who are dealing with anxiety, overthinking, and a harsh inner critic. Using CBT, we work on understanding your thought patterns and building practical tools that actually fit your life. All my sessions are telehealth, with daytime appointments on Mondays and Fridays, so you can meet from wherever feels comfortable. If this sounds like you, I'd love to help.

Next
Next

How Do I Quiet My Inner Critic? 5 Ways to Talk Back to That Harsh Inner Voice